Mini-Series - High Performance Decision-Making (Part 2)

👋 Hi, legend!

Thank you to those who gave feedback on last week’s mini-series edition. It looks like there might be some change afoot, but it’s not too late to let me know what you think via return email or poll!

Today’s edition is brought to you by 1440

Seeking impartial news? Meet 1440.

Every day, 3.5 million readers turn to 1440 for their factual news. We sift through 100+ sources to bring you a complete summary of politics, global events, business, and culture, all in a brief 5-minute email. Enjoy an impartial news experience.

Join for free today!

Please support The High Performance Brief and 1440 by clicking through and checking out their work.

🏆 The Winner’s Circle

Thanks to everyone who took part in the Amazon Gift Card referral giveaway—your support in building the newsletter means a lot. I’m excited to announce that the winner of this round was Matthew, who referred four new subscribers. Congratulations!

In Part 1 of this mini-series, we explored how probabilistic thinking allows you to quantify uncertainty and make more informed decisions. By assigning probabilities to potential outcomes, you shift your focus from perfection to optimisation, paving the way for smarter, faster choices.

But as we all know, the real world doesn’t operate in neat, static frameworks. New information emerges, circumstances evolve, and assumptions are challenged. In these moments, the best decision-makers don’t just stick to the plan—they adapt. This ability to pivot is what separates high performers from the rest.

In Part 2, we’ll dive into two frameworks that equip you to thrive in dynamic environments: Bayesian Updating and the OODA Loop (observe, orient, decide, act). These tools will enhance your ability to make effective decisions, and help you maintain flexibility as situations change. On face value they may seem overly intuitive and basic–”obviously I’m going to adjust my thinking with the situation”–but their strength is in the structure that they provide during uncertainty, and their role in prompting refreshed perspectives.

Bayesian Updating: A Tool For Real-Time Refinement

In uncertain situations, our initial assumptions are rarely complete. Bayesian Updating offers a systematic way to refine your beliefs as new evidence becomes available. It’s a model that prioritises adaptability and intellectual humility—qualities that are indispensable for anyone aiming to excel in high-pressure environments.

How It Works

Bayesian Updating starts with a “prior” belief—your initial assumption about the likelihood of an event (probabilistic thinking). When new data emerges, you adjust this belief by evaluating how consistent the new evidence is with your prior. Importantly, Bayesian Updating does not simply average the prior belief and the new data. Instead, it assigns weight to both based on their reliability (confidence). Strong evidence shifts the posterior belief closer to the new data, while weak evidence has less impact. The result is a “posterior” belief: a more accurate, up-to-date understanding of the situation.

In practice, imagine you’re leading a team launch for a new app designed to streamline personal finance management. Early market research suggests there’s a 70% chance that the app will meet its adoption targets within the first quarter. As the rollout begins, however, you gather new feedback: several users report confusion over the onboarding process, and a key competitor launches a similar app with an aggressive pricing strategy. Using Bayesian Updating, you reassess your confidence in the app’s success, adjusting for the likelihood of these challenges affecting adoption rates. When you account for confidence in the data, you project a new probability of 62%. This process helps you pivot quickly, prioritising an improved user experience and emphasising unique features in your marketing strategy. Once these actions are taken, it’s time to search for new data and adjust your modelling again.

Why It Matters

Bayesian Updating keeps your decision-making process dynamic by integrating new evidence into your existing knowledge. Instead of discarding prior information or overreacting to a single data point, it ensures that each new piece of evidence is weighted appropriately based on its reliability. This approach prevents overconfidence in one-off observations while refining your understanding over time. It’s particularly effective in high-stakes environments, where balancing the noise of irrelevant data against the signal of critical information can mean the difference between success and failure. If you have access to high quantities and/or quality of data, Bayesian Updating is an incredibly powerful way to approach uncertainty.

The OODA Loop: Speed And Precision In Dynamic Contexts

Originally developed by military strategist John Boyd, the OODA Loop is a framework for rapid decision-making in fast-changing environments. It’s built around four phases:

1️⃣ Observe: Gather data and situational awareness.

2️⃣ Orient: Analyse the data, account for context, and identify your options.

3️⃣ Decide: Choose the best course of action based on your analysis.

4️⃣ Act: Execute your decision while remaining alert to new developments.

The OODA Loop emphasises agility and repetition. It’s not about making the perfect decision—it’s about making decisions quickly enough to stay ahead of the curve.

How It Works

Imagine you’re a sports coach overseeing a must-win game. Midway through, the opposing team shifts tactics, catching your team off guard. You notice this quickly because you’re locked into a cycle of regular observation. Using the OODA Loop, you:

👁️ Observe: Notice the change in the opponent’s formation.

🧭 Orient: Analyse their new strategy and identify weaknesses.

☝️ Decide: Plan a counter-tactic that exploits those weaknesses.

🤸 Act: Implement the change during the next break in play.

This iterative process ensures you’re not locked into a static game plan. Instead, you’re continuously adapting to stay competitive. It sounds simple on paper, but how often have you watched your favourite sporting team run into the same obstacles over and over again? Even the elite coaches can struggle to observe and adapt during periods of high stress. It sounds backwards, but by automating your thinking cycles you force regular re-evaluation, which actually allows you to break out of dangerous patterns.

Why It Matters

In high-performance settings, speed often trumps perfection. The OODA Loop equips you to act decisively without waiting for perfect clarity. By cycling through its phases repeatedly, you’re able to outpace competitors, respond effectively to crises, and maintain control in unpredictable situations.

Combining Bayesian Updating And OODA

While Bayesian Updating and the OODA Loop are powerful on their own, their true strength might lie in their synergy. Bayesian Updating sharpens your understanding of the situation as new data emerges, while the OODA Loop ensures you’re acting on that understanding in real time. Together, they create a decision-making process that’s both thoughtful and agile.

Consider a new business in a turbulent market. Bayesian Updating helps the team refine their assumptions about customer preferences as they analyse sales data and user feedback. Simultaneously, the OODA Loop keeps them nimble, allowing them to adjust their product features, pricing, or marketing strategy as new insights come to light. The result? A team that’s not only responsive to change but actively leveraging it to gain a competitive edge.

With practice, these frameworks will become second nature. You’ll find yourself adapting with confidence and clarity, even in the most uncertain of circumstances.

Stay tuned for Part 3, where we’ll explore advanced tools for weighing risk and reward—and how to make decisions that pay off in the long run.

Speak soon,

Zac

Disclaimer: The High Performance Brief is for general education purposes only. The content is not a substitute for professional healthcare or psychological services. If you have any health/mental health concerns, please consult a qualified professional.